STATUS UPDATE || THE REACTIONS AGAINST MUSALMANDER KARANIYA(WHAT THE MUSLIMS SHOULD DO)

 

Veteran Nazrul Islam a former IPS officer of west bengal wrote a book Mushalmander Karaniya (What The Muslims Should Do) and published recently.Almost every page of the book contains hate speech against the Hindus of West Bengal. He wrote that the muslim community suffers in West Bengal as  the upper cast hindus in West Bengal dominates every sector's high level positions. He mentioned that "Bande Mataram" the national anthem of India is a song which hurts the Islamic sentiments. So being a Muslim, everyone should not sing this song. His book highly criticizes Rammohan Roy, Vidayasagar, Mahatma Gandhi and Bankim Chandra Chattopadhay in many pages also propagated hatred against the Hindu leaders  of West Bengal politics. Even he did not spare to blame the Chief Minister of West Bengal.

Onbehalf of  theIUFE team we highly condemn his inflammatory Book. Our regards must be made to the government of West Bengal for banning such a venomous anti-Hindu book which wants to destroy the ethnic Hindus of West Bengal. Writer Taslima Nasreen criticized Sunil Gangully for supporting this book and unmasked Sunil Ganguli's lies and character.  Also, Taslima Nasreen said she was molested by this writer Sunil Gangully when she used to reside in West Bengal.

REACTIONS : 

This is clearly an outrage! It is a typical tactic among extremists to blame Hindus and Jews anytime they can to cause upheaval and discontent. The remarks made in this book are highly inflammatory and have no basis in reality! We question the intention of extremists that in every occasion in which they want to dominate a region why they resort to repeated attempts at Ethnic Cleansing? Why not address the issues and search for solutions to problems rather than making highly inflammatory remarks and statements? Destroying humans in the interest of expansionist visions are not conducive or productive in obtaining a peaceful society! Self gain is contrary to universal participation in a world that is tolerant of all representatives of the world working to establish a peaceful co-existence.

Zemira Eli Natan(USA)

Executive Director

International Unity for Equality

Facebook page:  http://www.facebook.com/zemira.elinatan

Former IPS officer Nazrul Islam has shown his communal and fanatic attitude on his book. i want to  thank the WB Govt. for banning  this book and special thanx to IUFE team to give us an empirical article. It opened the real aspect of so called clean-shaved muzzi in the name of Islam.

Ripon Dey(BANGLADESH)

President Bangladesh National Hindu Youth Grand Alliance

Facebook page: http://www.facebook.com/rpndey

Mr.Nazrul Islam like Zakir Naik  who feed from Islamic jehad ideology has shown his true face with publish of his book.He ignored the internal flaws and factors of Muslim community which is responsible for retardation of the community. His remarks on Indian great writers & patriotic  leaders & not singing  the Indian national song once more shows his anti national Ideology. I condemn this book & his remarks on India national leaders & national songs & ask the west Bengal government beside ban of his book this anti national & Islamic terrorist ideologue should be brought to justice.

Fagirchand Chandihok(GERMANY)

Volunteer (Global Human Rights Defense)

Facebook page :  http://www.facebook.com/fagirchand.chandihok

Mushalmander Karaniya (What Muslims Should Do) this book's every page contains hate speeches & hatred against the hindus of west bengal.It is the shame of india that by using the loophole of freespeech some people propagates anti indian materials.Nazrul Islam wants to blame hindus by any means to hide the drawbacks and inefficiencies of muslim community.We congratulate west bengal govt for ostracizing this malicious book.

Achintya Das(INDIA)

Administrative Director

International Unity for Equality

 Of course Nazrul Islam's book is full of hate and communal passion. Hindus are right to feel indignant. Now they should channel their feelings not towards banning the book, which is a sign of weakness, but towards giving it a fitting reply. They must show where this hate comes from, namely the Islamic doctrine as laid down by Mohammed. After Hindus have patiently abided by the free circulation of this hateful book, they should enjoy the right to see this answer also in free circulation.

Koenraad Elst(BELGIUM)

Writer and Orientalist 

Wiki Page: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koenraad_Elst

Facebook Page: http://www.facebook.com/koenraad.elst.3

Blogs: koenraadelst.blogspot.com  /  koenraadelst.bharatvani.org

I think that this indian citizen, who was policeman all his life, and lived of India's money, and was supposed to serve all his life for his motherland Bharat, and defend Her from her ennemies inside and outside of Her territory, is a traitor... he is a traitor and a madman. If its true that in the book that he published, he attacked the hymn Vande Mataram, if its true that he attacked Mahatma Gandhi, etc. he is a madman, and a traitor... he doesnt deserve to live in India... he should go live with his dear muslim fellows... IN PAKISTAN

Shivanath Swami(PERU)
President of the World Shaiva Association

Facebook Page:http://www.facebook.com/sbhagawanshiva

My opinion of this book is that it is a complete work of fiction and should be classified as such. It speaks of one man's opinion and wishes, and is a figment of his delusional imagination. When there is no truth to a book, it is said to be fiction. If the islamic community were capable of handling high government positions, then they should apply for those positions. If the islamic community were capable of making unbiased decisions and were patriotic to the country they live in, they would be welcomed into politics. If the islamic community were interested in humanity and making advances in science, medicine, engineering, business and finance, they would be welcomed into countries. If the islamic community would assimilate themselves to the customs and traditions of the country they are living, and have respect for others, they would be welcomed as friends. However, the islamic community is not capable of handling any of the above. They only know how to put blame and insult on everyone and everything expecting everyone to accommodate them.

Judie Rose Manning(USA)

Healthcare Professional 

Facebook Page:  https://www.facebook.com/judi.manning1


Muslims have already committed quite enough horrors in India. The historian Koenard Elst in his book, Negationism in India, gives an estimate of 80 million Hindus killed in the total jihad by Muslims against India. [Koenard Elst, Negationism in India, Voice of India, New Delhi, 2002, pg. 34.] In fact, the country of India today is only half the size of ancient India, due to jihad. The mountains near India are called the Hindu Kush, meaning the “funeral pyre of the Hindus.” So, if Muslims have a problem with Hindus (just like they have a problem with Jews, Christians, Buddhists, Bahais and everyone else who is not a Muslim), let them go back to their Muslim lands, like Pakistan, instead, where they can fight with their fellow Muslims (as they also do), and leave the rest of us alone in peace.

~ Mark Bernstein, College Professor of History, New York, USA
 Facebook Page: http://www.facebook.com/MarkABernstein 

I believe that The Govt of West Bengal of India has taken the fair decision by shunning this venomous anti hindu communal book.West Bengal Govt's stand will be exalted for defending the  peace & equality in this state.Former IPS officer Nazrul Islam should be apprehended for dispersing  Anti National propaganda against the West Bengal  & majority Hindus.We cordially felicitate IUFE for imparting this subject to us.

Advocate Gobindo Chandra Pramanik,(BANGLADESH)

Secretary General, Bangladesh National Hindu Grand Alliance (Hindu Mohajote)

 Facebook Page: http://www.facebook.com/gcpramanik

I believe India , despite all the sorrow ,the massive murder made by several Muslim Invader in the history , built a Islam typical Indian , that is the price to pay to live today all in harmony and respect each other.
After so many centuries of foreign occupation, tentative of destroying the Sannatha Dharma, that is the right of Hindus majorities to, at least practice their faith in freedom, actually in this country minorities are more protect than the majority.
Meanwhile, if an Muslim does not feeling this country enough Islamic , he has the right to going away to Arabia Saudi, or Pakistan, but he hasn’t got the right to say India is not not a tolerant country how many Muslim in 1947 in India and now? How many Hindus in Pakistan in 1947 and now? How is intolerant Mister Nazrul Islam? You belong to the minority and this country permitted you to become officer ,the National song “Vande Mataram” say “salam” , many Muslims were hero of the independence , probably for your generation the life ( and free critic )was more easy .
Why not destroy the Taj-Mahal because some element are not enough Muslim, Mister Nazrul Islam?
The classical speculation from Christian Muslim or Marxist against “Brahmin” are logical because they are they are the protector of the Dharma, for that, they disturb you.
To finish, you should remember you name was also the name of the famous Bengali poet: Nazrul lslam a poet of tolerance loved both in WB and Bangladesh by both Muslim and Hindu.
An Indian officer, a real patriot hasn’t got the right to spread hatred between the communities, but has the duty to build-up the prosperity of the country, to teach tolerance or leaving the country.

Vande Maratam

Philippe Launay-Debnath(FRANCE)

Facebook Page:  https://www.facebook.com/launaypolash




This book is complete fiction. It interferes with the building of prosperity for the community! It promotes genocide and spreads hatred! It is parallel to the "Protocols of Zion", a book that promotes hatred against Jews. The Hindus of West Benagal have a right to exist and live free of oppression!

Yehuda Franki Meinhardt(ISRAEL)

Director of International Hasbara Project Like for Israel 

Facebook Page:  http://www.facebook.com/yehudamein

 

I am trying to help a Bangladeshi author, Salam Azad, who was arrested for blasphemy for a book he wrote that some Muslims said offended their religious sensibilities. Yet, right next to that country, in West Bengal India, someone is able to write a book that openly and intentionally offends Hindus. While the latter's book might be hateful, this is a clear demonstration of why we are right and they are wrong; why we are fighting on the side of freedom and they on the side of oppression.

Some years back, a group of Nazis conducted a march through the streets of heavily Jewish Skokie, Illinois. Many of that town's residents were Holocaust survivors and remember terrible times when Nazis marched through the streets. I was among several Jews ready to be present in Skokie when they did and stop the march. We could have but did not. The mark of a truly free society is its allowing the worst speech to occur; but I wonder what would have happened if someone in India write the same things about Muslims. Because I also recall being in Kolkata several years ago when the editor and publisher of The Statesman were arrested because some Muslims complained that a British article they reprinted "offended" them.
 

Richard Benkin( CHICAGO,USA )

Dr. Richard Benkin is an American Jewish human rights activist, founder of 'Interfaith Strength', journalist, writer and lecturer. He's also a member of Folks Magazine's Editorial Board since August 2011.

 Facebook Page:  http://www.facebook.com/drrbenkin

REACTIONS OF MORE PEOPLE WILL BE PUBLISHED SOON ON THIS POST SO STAY TUNED WITH US.